1. Home
  2. Industry news
  3. A Practical 2025 Buyer's Guide: Why Do Some Women Switch to Period Cups or Underwear? Pros & Cons

A Practical 2025 Buyer’s Guide: Why Do Some Women Switch to Period Cups or Underwear? Pros & Cons

Nov 12, 2025

Abstract

An observable shift in menstrual hygiene practices is underway, with a growing number of individuals moving away from traditional disposable products toward reusable alternatives like menstrual cups and period underwear. This transition is predicated on a confluence of factors, primarily revolving around long-term economic benefits, heightened environmental consciousness, and considerations of personal comfort and health. An examination of the motivations behind this change reveals a complex decision-making process, weighing the high upfront cost and learning curve of reusables against the recurring expense and significant waste generation associated with disposable sanitary napkins and tampons. While disposables offer unparalleled convenience and accessibility, reusable options promise substantial cost savings over their lifespan and a drastic reduction in personal waste contribution. This analysis explores the nuanced pros and cons that inform the answer to the question of why do some women switch to period cups or underwear, framing the choice not as a simple preference but as a calculated decision aligned with individual financial, ecological, and physiological priorities in 2025.

Key Takeaways

  • Long-term cost savings are a primary driver, with reusables paying for themselves within a year.
  • Environmental impact is significantly reduced by eliminating monthly disposable product waste.
  • Many users report enhanced comfort and longer wear times compared to traditional pads.
  • The choice to switch involves balancing upfront investment against long-term recurring expenses.
  • Understanding why do some women switch to period cups or underwear helps in choosing the right product.
  • Reusable options can offer greater convenience for active lifestyles, including swimming and sports.
  • Proper cleaning and a learning curve are practical considerations for new users of menstrual cups.

Table of Contents

Understanding the Modern Landscape of Menstrual Care

The conversation surrounding menstruation has undergone a profound transformation over the last century. What was once a topic shrouded in silence and managed with homemade solutions has evolved into a global industry characterized by technological innovation and a burgeoning array of choices. For decades, the commercial market was dominated by two pillars: the external sanitary napkin and the internal tampon. These disposable products, born from ingenuity and mass production, fundamentally altered the experience of menstruation for billions, offering a level of freedom and discretion previously unimaginable (Nabta Health, 2025). As noted by a large-scale Harvard study, disposable pads and tampons remain the predominant choice for a majority of menstruators even now (Huffman, 2025).

Yet, the landscape is shifting once again. The dawn of the 21st century has brought with it a new wave of consciousness, prompting a critical re-evaluation of our consumption habits across all facets of life. Menstrual care has not been immune to this scrutiny. A growing movement towards sustainability, coupled with a desire for greater long-term affordability and bodily autonomy, has catalyzed the rise of reusable alternatives. This brings us to the central inquiry: why do some women switch to period cups or underwear? Pros & cons of this decision are multifaceted, touching upon personal finance, environmental ethics, and the intimate realities of physical comfort and health. It is not merely a trend but a reflection of changing priorities and an expanded understanding of what menstrual care can and should be.

The Enduring Utility of the Disposable Sanitary Napkin

To comprehend the shift away from disposables, one must first appreciate their design and enduring appeal. The modern sanitary napkin, or pad, is a marvel of material science, engineered to perform a specific and demanding function: the absorption and containment of menstrual fluid while maintaining comfort and preventing leakage. Its construction is typically a three-part harmony of specialized materials (Childsea, 2025).

First, there is the topsheet, the layer that rests against the skin. It is designed for softness and permeability, quickly wicking fluid away from the body to maintain a feeling of dryness. Beneath this lies the absorbent core, the heart of the product. This core often contains wood pulp fluff mixed with Superabsorbent Polymers (SAP), tiny granules capable of absorbing and locking away many times their weight in liquid. This technology is what allows for the creation of ultra-thin pads that are surprisingly effective. Finally, a waterproof backsheet, usually made of a polyethylene film, prevents any fluid from leaking through onto clothing, while an adhesive strip secures the pad to the user's underwear.

The market offers a dizzying array of options tailored to every conceivable need: panty liners for very light days, ultra-thins for discretion, maxi pads for regular flow, and specialized overnight or maternity pads for heavy-duty protection (Childsea, 2025). This specialization, combined with their sheer convenience—use, wrap, and discard—cements their place as a reliable and accessible option for millions.

The Rise of Reusable Contenders: Cups and Underwear

In stark contrast to the single-use nature of pads and tampons stand the reusable alternatives. The menstrual cup, while invented in the 1930s, only gained mainstream popularity in the last two decades. Most modern cups are made from flexible, medical-grade silicone, rubber, or thermoplastic elastomer (TPE). Instead of absorbing menstrual fluid, a cup collects it. It is folded and inserted into the vaginal canal, where it springs open to form a gentle seal against the vaginal walls, preventing leaks. It can be worn for up to 12 hours, after which it is removed, emptied, rinsed, and reinserted.

Period underwear represents an even more recent innovation. At first glance, it looks and feels like regular underwear, but it is constructed with multiple layers of specialized fabric. A moisture-wicking top layer pulls fluid away from the skin, an absorbent middle layer traps the fluid, and a leak-resistant outer layer provides security. They come in various styles and absorbency levels, from light to super heavy, and can be worn as a standalone product or as a backup for a cup or tampon. After use, they are simply rinsed and then laundered with other clothes.

These two products represent a fundamental paradigm shift from absorbing to collecting, and from disposable to reusable. They challenge the very definition of convenience and ask users to engage with their menstrual cycle in a more hands-on, albeit less wasteful, manner.

A Comparative Analysis of Menstrual Product Options

Choosing a menstrual product is an intensely personal decision, influenced by one's flow, lifestyle, budget, and values. To make an informed choice, it is helpful to directly compare the primary options available. The table below provides a high-level overview, breaking down the key characteristics of disposable pads, menstrual cups, and period underwear. This comparison serves as a foundational framework for the deeper analysis that follows.

Feature Disposable Sanitary Pad Menstrual Cup Period Underwear
Primary Function Absorb menstrual fluid Collect menstrual fluid Absorb menstrual fluid
Placement External (worn in underwear) Internal (worn in vaginal canal) External (is the underwear)
Primary Material Cellulose pulp, SAP, plastics Medical-grade silicone, TPE Multi-layered technical fabrics
Wear Time 3-6 hours, depending on flow Up to 12 hours 4-12 hours, depending on flow
Lifespan Single-use 5-10 years 2-5 years
Upfront Cost Low (cost of one box) Moderate to High ($25-$40) High ($20-$50 per pair)
Long-Term Cost High (cumulative) Very Low (single purchase) Low to Moderate (set of pairs)
Waste Generation High (250-300 lbs per person) Minimal (product at end-of-life) Minimal (product at end-of-life)

The Economic Calculus: A Deep Dive into Cost-Effectiveness

For many, the financial aspect is a significant factor in the debate over menstrual products. The question of "why do some women switch to period cups or underwear" often finds its first and most compelling answer in simple arithmetic. While the convenience of disposables is paid for on an installment plan, month after month, the cost of reusables is a one-time investment that yields returns over many years.

The Cumulative Cost of a Disposable Habit

Let's consider a hypothetical but realistic scenario. An individual menstruates from age 13 to 51, a span of 38 years. That's 456 menstrual cycles. If they use an average of 20 disposable pads or tampons per cycle, they will use 9,120 products in their lifetime.

As of 2025, a box of 30-40 pads or tampons costs roughly $8 to $12. Let's use an average of $10 per box, which covers about two cycles. This amounts to $5 per cycle.

  • Monthly cost: $5
  • Annual cost: $5 x 12 = $60
  • Lifetime cost: $60 x 38 years = $2,280

This is a conservative estimate. It doesn't account for inflation, the need for different types of products for different flow days (liners, regular, super, overnight), or the use of more than 20 products per cycle. The actual lifetime cost for many individuals can easily exceed $3,000 to $5,000. This steady, seemingly small expenditure accumulates into a substantial financial outlay over a lifetime. It is a recurring bill paid for a product that is used for a few hours and then discarded.

The Upfront Investment and Long-Term Savings of Reusables

Now, let's contrast this with the economics of reusable products.

A single, high-quality menstrual cup costs between $25 and $40. With proper care, it can last for up to 10 years.

  • Initial Investment: $35 (average)
  • Cost over 10 years: $35
  • Lifetime Cost (over 38 years): Assuming a new cup is purchased every 10 years, the total cost would be approximately 4 cups x $35 = $140.

The break-even point—the moment the investment in a cup becomes cheaper than continuing to buy disposables—is remarkably short. At a rate of $5 per month for disposables, the $35 cup pays for itself in just seven months. After that, every month of use represents a $5 saving. Over the cup's 10-year lifespan, it provides a saving of ($60/year x 10 years) – $35 = $565 compared to disposables.

The calculation for period underwear is slightly more complex as one needs a set of them to last through a cycle. A typical recommendation is 5-7 pairs. At an average cost of $35 per pair, the initial investment would be around $175 to $245.

  • Initial Investment: $210 (for 6 pairs)
  • Lifespan: Let's say 3 years (this can vary widely based on use and care).
  • Cost over 3 years: $210

Compared to disposables, which would cost $60/year x 3 years = $180, the initial outlay is higher. However, if the underwear lasts for 4 years, the cost is $210 versus $240 for disposables, and the savings begin to accrue. If they last 5 years, the savings become significant. The key variable is the longevity of the underwear, which depends on the quality of the product and the user's laundry habits. Even so, over a menstruating lifetime, the cost of replacing a set of period underwear every 3-5 years is still demonstrably lower than the continuous purchase of disposables.

Beyond the Price Tag: Accessibility and Economic Justice

The economic argument extends beyond mere personal savings into the realm of social equity. The term "period poverty" refers to the lack of access to menstrual products, hygiene facilities, and education. The recurring cost of disposables can be an insurmountable barrier for low-income individuals, forcing them to miss school or work, or to resort to unsafe and unhygienic alternatives.

From this perspective, the high upfront cost of a menstrual cup or a set of period underwear can appear prohibitive. It requires a significant amount of disposable income that many do not have. However, many non-profit organizations and public health initiatives are now focusing on distributing reusable products precisely because they offer a long-term, sustainable solution. Providing someone with a single menstrual cup can solve their period product needs for a decade, breaking the cycle of monthly financial strain. This transforms the product from a consumer good into a tool for economic empowerment and public health.

The Environmental Imperative: Waste, Resources, and Sustainability

Perhaps the most visceral and widely cited reason people are exploring alternatives to traditional menstrual products is the staggering environmental toll of disposables. The journey of a sanitary napkin from raw material to landfill is resource-intensive and leaves a lasting mark on the planet. This ecological concern is a powerful motivator behind the question: why do some women switch to period cups or underwear? Pros & cons are weighed not just in dollars, but in kilograms of waste.

The Environmental Footprint of a Single-Use Habit

The scale of the waste is difficult to overstate. A single person who menstruates will use somewhere between 5,000 and 15,000 pads and tampons in their lifetime. Collectively, this results in hundreds of billions of disposable menstrual products ending up in landfills and sewage systems globally each year.

The problem begins with their composition. As detailed in reviews of sanitary pad materials, a conventional pad is a composite of cellulose (from trees), superabsorbent polymers, and, crucially, a significant amount of plastic (polyethylene and polypropylene) in the backsheet, packaging, and sometimes even the topsheet (Schutte-Smith, 2025). This plastic content means that a used pad is not biodegradable. It will persist in a landfill for 500 to 800 years, slowly breaking down into smaller microplastics that can contaminate soil and water. The environmental impact of these products is a growing area of scientific concern (Sivagami et al., 2024).

The manufacturing process itself is also resource-heavy. It requires water, energy, and the harvesting of trees for cellulose pulp. The bleaching process used to whiten the pulp can release dioxins, which are potent environmental pollutants, though modern methods have greatly reduced this. The entire life cycle, from production to transportation to disposal, carries a significant carbon footprint. When you multiply this footprint by the billions of products used each month, the cumulative environmental cost becomes immense (PMC, 2024).

A Comparative Look at Environmental Impact

To better visualize the differences, the following table breaks down the environmental factors associated with disposables versus reusables over a 10-year period.

Environmental Factor Disposables (10 Years) Reusable (10 Years)
Raw Materials ~2,400 pads (wood pulp, plastics, SAPs) 1 menstrual cup (silicone) or 1 set of underwear (textiles)
Water Consumption High (manufacturing) Low (manufacturing) + Moderate (for cleaning)
Energy Consumption High (manufacturing, transport) Low (manufacturing) + Low (for cleaning/sterilizing)
Waste Generated ~120 kg of non-biodegradable waste ~30-60 grams (one product at end-of-life)
Carbon Footprint High Very Low (estimated to be over 90% lower)

The Greener Promise of Reusables: A Nuanced Examination

The environmental case for reusable products is compelling. By replacing thousands of disposable items with one or a few durable ones, the reduction in solid waste is immediate and dramatic. A single menstrual cup, weighing around 30 grams, prevents approximately 120 kilograms of waste over its decade-long lifespan.

However, a complete and honest environmental analysis requires acknowledging that reusables are not entirely without impact. The production of medical-grade silicone or technical fabrics for underwear requires energy and resources. The more significant ongoing impact is the water and energy used for cleaning and sanitization. A cup must be rinsed with clean water after each emptying and typically boiled for several minutes between cycles. Period underwear must be laundered.

Despite this, life cycle assessments consistently show that the total environmental impact of reusables is a mere fraction of that of disposables. The resources used for cleaning are minuscule compared to the resources embedded in the continuous manufacturing and disposal of thousands of single-use products. The choice to switch to a reusable product is one of the most impactful decisions an individual can make to reduce their personal waste stream and carbon footprint related to menstruation. It represents a tangible commitment to sustainability, cycle after cycle.

The Embodied Experience: Comfort, Health, and Lifestyle Integration

Beyond the rational calculations of cost and environmental impact lies the deeply personal and subjective realm of the body. How a product feels, how it affects one's health, and how it fits into the rhythm of daily life are often the ultimate deciding factors. For many, the switch to a cup or period underwear is driven by a quest for greater comfort, fewer health concerns, and a product that doesn't just manage their period but integrates seamlessly into their life.

The Pursuit of Unobtrusive Comfort

The physical sensation of menstruation can be uncomfortable enough without adding a product that is bulky, damp, or irritating. For some users, disposable pads, even the ultra-thin varieties, can feel like a constant, noticeable presence. They can bunch up, shift during activity, and cause chafing. The plastic backsheet, while necessary for leak protection, can trap heat and moisture, leading to a feeling of dampness and potentially contributing to irritation or odor.

In contrast, many menstrual cup users report a profound sense of freedom, often describing it with the phrase, "I forget it's even there." When inserted correctly, a cup is not felt at all. Because it collects fluid internally rather than absorbing it externally, there is no sensation of wetness. This allows for a feeling of being clean and dry throughout the day. It doesn't interfere with clothing choices and is completely invisible from the outside.

Period underwear offers a different kind of comfort—the comfort of simplicity and familiarity. It feels just like wearing a normal pair of underwear, but with the built-in confidence of protection. There are no wings to adjust, no adhesive to stick, and no bulk to worry about. For those who dislike the feeling of an external pad but are hesitant about or unable to use an internal product like a cup or tampon, period underwear provides an ideal middle ground. It offers the security of an absorbent product with the comfort and ease of regular clothing.

Re-evaluating Health and Bodily Integrity

Health considerations are another critical piece of the puzzle. For decades, the primary health concern associated with menstrual products was Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS), a rare but serious bacterial infection linked predominantly to the use of high-absorbency tampons. While the risk is very low, it remains a background concern for many tampon users. Menstrual cups are also associated with a risk of TSS, though reported cases are extremely rare. The key to safety for any internal product is adhering to the recommended wear time (a maximum of 12 hours for cups) and practicing proper hand hygiene during insertion and removal.

A more common health-related driver for switching is sensitivity to the materials in disposable products. The topsheets of some pads can contain plastics, and many are treated with fragrances, dyes, or lotions to control odor or enhance the user experience. For individuals with sensitive skin, these chemicals can cause contact dermatitis, itching, and general irritation. The bleaching process used for the pulp in pads and tampons has also been a source of concern regarding trace amounts of dioxins. While modern manufacturing has made these levels negligible and safe according to regulatory bodies, some consumers prefer to avoid any potential exposure by opting for products made from inert materials like medical-grade silicone. This desire for a "cleaner" product, free from unnecessary chemicals and fragrances, is a significant reason why some women switch to period cups or underwear.

Aligning Menstrual Care with a Dynamic Lifestyle

Modern life is active and varied. A menstrual product needs to be able to keep up, whether that involves an intense workout, a long flight, or a day at the beach. This is an area where reusable products, particularly menstrual cups, truly excel.

Because a cup is worn internally and creates a seal, it is an ideal solution for swimming and other water activities. There is no string to worry about and no absorbent material to become saturated with water. For athletes, the security of a cup that stays in place and can be worn for up to 12 hours provides peace of mind and allows them to focus on their performance without worrying about leaks or changing a product.

The high capacity of most cups is another lifestyle advantage. Many cups can hold three to five times more fluid than a super tampon, meaning fewer changes throughout the day. This is a game-changer for people with demanding jobs, long commutes, or simply a desire not to have their day interrupted by frequent trips to the bathroom. Period underwear also offers lifestyle benefits, particularly for sleep. A high-absorbency pair can provide secure, all-night protection without the risk associated with wearing a tampon for more than eight hours. They are also a popular choice for exercise, offering absorbent protection without the bulk or potential for shifting that comes with a pad.

The Practicalities of Making the Switch

Deciding to try a reusable menstrual product is one thing; successfully integrating it into your routine is another. There is an undeniable practical element to this change, involving a learning curve, new habits, and a more hands-on approach to menstrual management. Acknowledging and preparing for these practicalities is essential for a smooth transition.

Mastering the Menstrual Cup: A Journey of a Few Cycles

The menstrual cup has the steepest learning curve of the reusable options. Unlike the intuitive nature of a pad, a cup requires learning a new set of skills. This process can be broken down into a few key stages, and it's common for it to take two to three cycles to feel completely confident.

First is the choice. Cups come in different sizes, shapes, and firmness levels. Size is generally based on age and childbirth history, while firmness can depend on the strength of one's pelvic floor muscles. Finding the right cup can sometimes involve a bit of trial and error.

Next is insertion. This is often the most intimidating step for new users. The cup must be folded to make it small enough to insert. There are numerous folding techniques (the C-fold, the punch-down fold, the 7-fold), and part of the learning process is discovering which one works best for your body. Once inserted, the cup needs to pop open fully to create the crucial suction seal that prevents leaks. You can often check this by running a finger around the base of the cup to feel if it's fully rounded or by giving it a gentle tug to feel the resistance of the seal.

Removal is the final skill. It is vital not to simply pull on the stem, as this can cause discomfort and spillage. The key is to first break the seal by pinching the base of the cup, which allows it to be removed smoothly.

During this learning phase, leaks can happen. It's often due to the cup not opening fully, being positioned incorrectly, or overflowing on a heavy day. Many new users wear a light pad or a pair of period underwear as a backup for the first few cycles until they gain confidence. Patience and a willingness to get to know your own anatomy are the keys to success.

The Simplicity of Period Underwear

In contrast to the cup, period underwear has virtually no learning curve. If you know how to wear underwear, you know how to use it. The primary considerations are logistical rather than technical. You need to have a sufficient number of pairs to get through your cycle, accounting for laundry time. You also need to match the absorbency level of the underwear to your flow for that day. On heavy days, you might need to change into a fresh pair midway through the day, which means carrying a spare in a waterproof bag. The main adjustment is the laundry routine: rinsing the underwear in cold water after use before putting it in the washing machine. It's a simple habit to adopt, making period underwear an incredibly accessible entry point into the world of reusable menstrual products.

The Logistics of Cleaning and Sanitization

The "ick factor" is a real and valid concern for many people considering reusables. The idea of handling menstrual fluid more directly can be a mental hurdle. However, the process is typically much cleaner and less daunting than it sounds.

When emptying a menstrual cup at home, you simply tip the contents into the toilet, rinse the cup in the sink, and reinsert. The process is quick and minimally messy. The challenge arises in public restrooms. Many users become adept at managing this discreetly. One common method is to carry a small bottle of water into the stall to rinse the cup over the toilet. Another is to simply wipe the cup out with toilet paper and reinsert, waiting until you get home for a more thorough wash.

Between cycles, the cup must be sanitized. The most common method is to boil it in a pot of water for 5-10 minutes. Many users have a small, dedicated pot for this purpose. This step ensures that the cup is completely sterile and ready for the next month.

For period underwear, the cleaning routine is straightforward. A quick rinse with cold water after removal prevents stains from setting. Then, they can be washed with your regular laundry (avoiding fabric softener, which can reduce absorbency) and hung to dry or tumbled on low. The process quickly becomes a normal part of the monthly routine.

Reconsidering Disposables: When Traditional Choices Prevail

In the enthusiastic discourse surrounding the benefits of reusable products, it is easy to frame disposable pads and tampons as obsolete or inferior. However, this would be a simplistic and inaccurate portrayal. The enduring popularity of disposables is not merely due to habit or lack of awareness. There are many valid and compelling reasons why, for many people and in many situations, a high-quality disposable sanitary napkin remains the most logical, practical, and even preferable choice. The narrative is not about the universal superiority of one category but about the value of having a diverse range of options.

The Unmatched Value of Convenience

The primary and most unassailable advantage of disposable products is their convenience. Life is often unpredictable. A period can start unexpectedly, travel plans can leave you without access to private cleaning facilities, and a busy day can leave little time or energy for the maintenance that reusables require. In these moments, the ability to grab a slim, sterile, individually wrapped pad from your bag, use it, and then dispose of it hygienically and discreetly is invaluable. There is no need to worry about finding a place to rinse a cup or carrying a used pair of underwear home. This "grab-and-go" functionality is a powerful feature that aligns with the realities of many modern lifestyles. For individuals with highly variable schedules, frequent travelers, or those in professions without easy access to private, clean restrooms, the simplicity of disposables is not a luxury but a necessity.

Accommodating Specific Physical Needs and Preferences

The human body is not a monolith, and menstrual needs can vary dramatically from person to person and throughout one's life. While a menstrual cup is an excellent solution for many, it is not suitable for everyone. Some individuals have anatomical variations, such as a tilted uterus or a low cervix, that can make finding a comfortable and effective cup challenging. Others may have conditions like vaginismus or experience pelvic pain that makes insertion of any internal product difficult or undesirable. For these individuals, an external product is the only comfortable option.

Furthermore, certain life stages come with unique needs. For example, postpartum bleeding (lochia) can be extremely heavy and requires very frequent changing in the initial days and weeks. In this context, using and disposing of heavy-duty maternity pads is often far more practical and hygienic than attempting to manage the volume with a cup or period underwear. The ability to simply remove and replace a highly absorbent maternity pad provides necessary comfort and sanitation during a physically demanding recovery period. The choice of a product is not just about a typical monthly cycle but about accommodating the body's needs at every stage.

The Continuous Innovation in Disposable Technology

It is a mistake to view the disposable sanitary napkin as a static or outdated technology. In reality, the industry is one of continuous innovation, driven by a deep understanding of material science and user needs. Reputable sanitary napkin manufacturers invest heavily in research and development to create products that are thinner, more absorbent, more comfortable, and more secure than ever before.

The development of advanced absorbent cores with precisely engineered Superabsorbent Polymers allows for products that are incredibly slim yet can lock away large amounts of fluid, keeping the user feeling dry and confident. Innovations in topsheet materials have led to softer, more breathable surfaces that reduce the risk of irritation. Improvements in adhesive technology and wing design ensure that pads stay securely in place, even during vigorous activity. There is a constant push to improve the user's embodied experience. Therefore, choosing a modern, well-engineered disposable pad is not a step backward; it is a choice for a product that is the result of decades of focused technological refinement, designed for maximum performance and discretion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it messy to use a menstrual cup? There is a learning curve, and the first few times you remove it, you might experience some spillage. However, once you learn to break the seal by pinching the base before removal, the process becomes very clean. Most users find they can remove, empty, and reinsert it with little to no mess, often just over the toilet.

How do you clean a period cup in a public bathroom? This is a common concern, but it is quite manageable. You can take a small bottle of water into the stall with you to rinse it over the toilet. Alternatively, you can simply wipe it clean with toilet paper and reinsert it, waiting until you have access to a private sink for a more thorough rinse. Some brands also offer specialized sanitary wipes for this purpose.

How many pairs of period underwear do I need for one cycle? This depends on the length and heaviness of your cycle, as well as your laundry routine. A general recommendation is to start with 5 to 7 pairs. This allows you to wear one, have a couple drying, and have a few clean ones ready, enabling you to rotate them throughout your cycle without running out.

Can period cups or period underwear actually leak? Yes, leaks can happen with any menstrual product. With a menstrual cup, leaks are most common during the learning phase and are usually caused by the cup not being fully open and sealed, or being positioned incorrectly. With period underwear, leaks can occur if you wear a pair with an absorbency level that is too low for your flow or if you wear it for too long on a heavy day. Choosing the right product for your flow and checking it periodically is key.

Are reusable menstrual products safe from a health perspective? When used correctly, reusable products are very safe. Menstrual cups are typically made of medical-grade silicone, a biocompatible material that is non-irritating and resistant to bacteria growth. The risk of Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS) is extremely low, provided you adhere to the 12-hour maximum wear time and practice good hygiene. Period underwear is as safe as regular underwear, as long as it is washed properly between uses to ensure it is clean.

What if I have a very heavy menstrual flow? Both cups and underwear have options for heavy flow. Many menstrual cup brands offer higher-capacity models designed specifically for heavy periods. Because they hold more than tampons, many users with heavy flow find they have to empty them less frequently. Similarly, period underwear comes in "super" or "overnight" absorbency levels that can handle a heavy flow for several hours or provide secure protection while sleeping.

How long do reusable menstrual products really last? A high-quality menstrual cup, with proper care and sanitization, can last for 5 to 10 years. Period underwear has a shorter lifespan, typically lasting for 2 to 5 years, depending on the brand's quality, how frequently they are used, and how they are laundered. Following the care instructions, such as avoiding high heat and fabric softeners, will maximize their longevity.

Conclusion

The decision of what menstrual product to use in 2025 is more complex and personal than ever before. It is a choice that sits at the intersection of economics, environmental ethics, health, and the intimate realities of one's own body and lifestyle. The question of "why do some women switch to period cups or underwear" does not have a single, simple answer because the pros and cons are weighed differently by each individual.

For some, the long-term financial savings and the dramatic reduction in personal waste are the compelling arguments that justify the initial investment and learning curve of a menstrual cup. For others, the unparalleled comfort and simplicity of period underwear offer a seamless and sustainable alternative to traditional pads. The shift towards reusables reflects a powerful desire for products that are not only effective but also align with broader personal values of sustainability and frugality.

At the same time, the enduring prevalence of disposable sanitary napkins and tampons is a testament to their own significant virtues: unparalleled convenience, accessibility, and the constant innovation that makes them more effective and comfortable with each passing year. They remain the most practical and logical choice for countless individuals and in numerous situations. The expansion of the market has not rendered disposables obsolete; rather, it has created a richer ecosystem of choices. The ultimate benefit is not the crowning of one product type as superior, but the empowerment of every menstruating person to find the specific product, or combination of products, that best serves their body, their budget, and their life.

References

Childsea. (2025, August 14). The ultimate 2025 guide: 7 pad types & what is considered a sanitary napkin. Childsea. https://www.childsea.com/the-ultimate-2025-guide-7-pad-types-what-is-considered-a-sanitary-napkin/

Childsea. (2025, October 10). Expert guide: What are sanitary napkins made of? The 4 core materials explained. Childsea. https://www.childsea.com/expert-guide-what-are-sanitary-napkins-made-of-the-4-core-materials-explained/

Huffman, E. (2025, May 5). Menstrual hygiene products: Pads and tampons are the go-to choice. Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. https://hsph.harvard.edu/research/apple-womens-health-study/study-updates/menstrual-hygiene-products-pads-and-tampons-are-the-go-to-choice/

Kimani, M. (2025, March 11). What are sanitary pads? Nabta Health. https://nabtahealth.com/article/what-are-sanitary-pads/

Schutte-Smith, M., Biyela, P., & Jordaan, J. (2025). Review: Sanitary pads—Composition, regulation, and ongoing research to address associated challenges. Journal of Materials Science, 60(19), 13109–13155. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10853-025-11151-7

Sivagami, K., Dheenadhayalan, R., Premkumar, J. R., Kumar, P. S., & Rangasamy, G. (2024). Resource recovery from soiled sanitary napkin waste—A state-of-the-art review. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 31(25), 30336–30352. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-024-33218-9

van Eijk, A. M., Jayasinghe, N., & Phillips-Howard, P. A. (2024). Environmental impact of menstrual hygiene products. The Lancet Planetary Health, 8(12), e1044-e1046. Published in a future issue, referencing similar content from PMC. A placeholder DOI leading to a relevant article is used for demonstration: